top of page

Why Can Sitting Hurt More Than Exercise?

Writer: Patrick  Jennings
Patrick Jennings
Sep 29
3 min read

Here's something that often surprises people in clinic:

They can go for a walk, do a gym session or spend an hour exercising and feel absolutely fine...

…but 45 minutes sitting in the car leaves their body aching.

Or they feel great while they're moving around all weekend, only for their neck and shoulders to start complaining when they're back at their desk on Monday.

It seems backwards.

Surely exercise puts more strain on the body than sitting?

Not necessarily.

Your Body Was Made To Move

We sometimes think of movement as something that wears our bodies out.

If my back hurts, I should rest it.

If my knee aches, I shouldn't load it.

If my shoulder is sore, I should avoid using it.

Sometimes a short period of modifying activity is sensible.

But in many cases, movement is actually one of the things our bodies respond best to.

Walking gets your joints moving.

Strength training progressively exposes your muscles and joints to load.

Changing position distributes demand across different areas.

And regular movement stops you spending hours loading exactly the same tissues in exactly the same way.

Sitting Isn't The Enemy

After last week's email, this is worth repeating.

Sitting isn't bad for you.

There's nothing inherently wrong with sitting on the sofa, working at a desk or

spending an evening watching television.

The problem is often how long you stay there.

Think about holding your arm out in front of you.

For ten seconds? Easy.

For a minute? Still manageable.

For an hour?

Suddenly something that required very little effort becomes extremely uncomfortable.

Sitting can be similar.

The position itself isn't necessarily the problem.

It's the duration.

Why Do I Feel Better When I'm Moving?

This is something I hear regularly:

"It's fine when I'm walking around. It's when I stop that it starts hurting."

That isn't unusual.

When you're moving, you're constantly changing the load going through your muscles and joints.

Nothing stays completely still for very long.

Then you sit down at your desk for two hours and suddenly one area is being asked to tolerate the same position continuously.

That's why people can sometimes tolerate a surprising amount of activity but struggle with relatively sedentary things like:

  • Long car journeys

  • Sitting at a desk

  • Flights

  • Watching television

  • Long meetings

  • Standing still for prolonged periods

Notice I included standing there too.

Because this isn't really a sitting problem.

It's a not-moving-for-a-long-time problem.

Don't Be Scared Of Loading Your Body

This is probably the most important message in today's email.

Your body isn't something you need to protect from every bit of load.

It needs load.

Muscles become stronger because we challenge them.

Bones respond to weight-bearing activity.

Our cardiovascular system improves when we make it work.

And our bodies become better at tolerating the things we regularly ask them to do.

That doesn't mean going from doing nothing to lifting the heaviest weights you can find.

It means gradually exposing your body to appropriate levels of activity and allowing it to adapt.

What If Exercise Hurts?

This is where things become more individual.

Some discomfort during or after activity doesn't automatically mean you've caused damage.

But persistent, worsening or significant pain shouldn't simply be ignored either.

If something repeatedly hurts whenever you exercise, the answer isn't necessarily:

"Stop exercising."

Sometimes the better questions are:

Why does this particular movement hurt?

Can we modify it?

Is the load appropriate?

Is there another way to keep you active while we work on the problem?

The aim should usually be to find a way to keep you moving, rather than removing movement altogether.

Movement Doesn't Have To Mean Exercise

And finally, don't confuse movement with having to go to the gym.

Walking the dog counts.

Gardening counts.

Playing with the kids counts.

Taking the stairs counts.

Getting up from your desk counts.

Going for a wander at lunchtime counts.

Your body doesn't know whether you've labelled something "exercise".

It just knows you're moving.

"Your body isn't designed to avoid load. It's designed to adapt to it."

So if you regularly feel worse after sitting still than you do after moving around, you're certainly not alone.

And perhaps the answer isn't finding an even more comfortable chair.

It might simply be giving your body more opportunities to do what it was built to do.

Move.

Recent Posts

See All
Do You Need to Stretch More As You Get Older?

“I really need to stretch more.” It's something I hear in clinic all the time. Usually after someone has stood up from a chair and made a noise they weren't expecting. Feeling stiffer than you used to

 
 
 
Should You Still Lift Weights As You Get Older?

"I'm getting a bit old for lifting weights now, aren't I?" It's something I hear regularly in clinic. And interestingly, it's a question I get from both men and women. People who used to go to the gym

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page